Science-advisor
REGISTER info/FAQ
Login
username
password
forgot password?
register here for free...
 
Research articles
  search articles
  reviews guidelines
  reviews
  articles index
My Pages
my alerts
  my messages
  my reviews
  my favorites
 
 
Statistics
Members: 1476
Articles: 1'346'278
Articles rated: 1486

04 September 2010
 
  > > review 05090018

  Science-advisor review


SCIENCE-ADVISOR - review - "Magnetisation in the 2DXY model?..."
Science-advisor.net review 05090018 (2 readers)    * Rate this comment.
Article reference: Phase Transition with the Berezinskii--Kosterlitz--Thouless Singularity in the Ising Model on a Growing Network.
Review title: Magnetisation in the 2DXY model?
Reviewer: reviewer20
Date: 23 September 2005 at 13:47 GMT.
Read this article?: maybe for the model itself
Comment: It seems that there is a problem of interpretation in this articel. There is no long range order parameter the BKT phase transition because of the Mermin-Wagner theorem at least in the 2DXY model. The magnetisation M is 0 at all temperatures for the 2DXY model. The magnetisation found in this article $M =exp(-c/(\sqrt{T_c-T})$ could be related to a 3DXY or something like that.
I don't understand the BKT interpretation in this article.

important: 2,    broad interest: 2,    readable: 3,    new: 2,    correct: 1,   Global: 2
Article rating: 2/5





ScienXe.org
-Autonomous Website Creator for Scientists
-Online CV
-Free


News, jobs and information for researchers on myScience:
myScience UK
myScience USA
myScience Switzerland
myScience Germany
myScience International (over 7000 science jobs).
home  |  contact  |  terms of use  |  sitemap
Copyright © 2005-2010 - Scimetrica