  
  
Statistics 
Members: 1884 Articles: 1'772'704 Articles rated: 2547
25 March 2017 

   

Scienceadvisor review
 

SCIENCEADVISOR  review  "A landmark paper solves tectonics puzzle..."
Scienceadvisor.net review 06080043 (5 readers)
Rate this comment.   Article reference:
Springtideinduced magnification of Earth mantle resonance causes tectonics and conceals universality of physics at all scales.   Review title: 
A landmark paper solves tectonics puzzle and computes Newtonian constant of gravitation  Reviewer: 
reviewer333  Date: 
27 August 2006 at 02:52 GMT.  Read this article?: 
It is the first correct prediction of a physical constant in history  Comment:  This must be one of the most incredible papers I read in decades. The author (who is a geophysicist) first shows that the earth shakes due to springtidal resonance of its mantle! This is all pretty basic calculus and I don’t see how anyone in or outside the field of geophysics will be able to dispute its correctness. Even if it’s one of the most unusual papers they will read. Observations that were made using superconducting gravimeter support the model. The model was demonstrated as standing in excellent agreement with straightforward formulas of forced oscillator. (Dr. Omerbaschich also claims that his resonance is responsible for Gexperiments' inconsistencies, the earth magnetic field and some other phenomena.) As if that alone was not a huge claim to make, the author takes it even further. In order to prove that natural forced oscillators such as earthmoon are real, he posits that the universe consists of (almost) infinitely many such forced oscillators! It ends with a theory according to which the vacuum energy (the author calls it dark matter/energy, but I think that was an unnecessary mystification) vibrates while carrying – gravitation! There is another twist: gravity is not attractive but REPULSIVE i.e. it propagates FORWARD. What's more: it does it MECHANICALLY i.e. so that each particle's orbit interacts with to it adjacent particle orbit(s) by locking into a single forced oscillator, and so on. If this were "just another wacky theory", believe me – I would have not bothered. But it contains many remarkable expressions, and as far as I could tell they are all correct! The most remarkable however seems Dr. Omerbashich’s closing argument: G (and not physics!) changes with scale, so that both quantum mechanics and relativity theory were conceived on cardinally flawed premises (given that the Planck’s constant is determined via instrumentation that gets affected by the springtide in the same manner in which gravimeters are shown). To show that he is not all about talking, Dr. Omerbaschich demonstrates with total serenity that his model predicts (correctly mind you, I did run the numbers) the currently accepted experimental values of the Newtonian constant on both mechanical and Planck scales. (The formula also predicts G on the stringsize as well as universesize scales, too.) Just one simple formula does it all – a formula which, according to my book, represents the first theoretical prediction of experimental value of a physical constant in history. There is no doubt in my mind that G=se2 is to make history, on a par with E=mc2. 
important: 5,
broad interest: 5,
readable: 4,
new: 5,
correct: 5,
Global: 5
 Article rating:
4.83/5 


 


